[dc]A[/dc]s I promised last week, I’m going to start posting on some different topics and broadening the scope of this blog a little bit. (Depending on the reception, maybe a lot, but we will see.) Let’s jump off today by starting to think a little bit about meditation. I read this article yesterday, which is an interesting introduction to the subject. There are many things in that article I might take issue with, but it’s probably a good place to start if you’re starting from scratch.
I’ve been involved with meditation since my early college years when I worked with biofeedback machines to improve my performance as a musician, and had at least hints of the experience in some of my martial arts training when I was a kid. I’ve always thought of meditation as a sort of “mental technology” that allows us to make changes to our minds and our bodies. (If you think the benefits must be limited to our minds, at least accept the possibility that they might extend to the body as a possibility.) For many decades, I certainly knew more about meditation than the average person on the street, but I have a confession: I wasn’t very good at it and I didn’t do it very much.
I think much of the problem is that I have the attention span of a common housefly. For instance, there was a point this weekend where I was watching something on television, making cookies, reading a book, chatting on my phone, and browsing on my tablet, all at the same time while drinking a cup of tea, and I realize this is fairly normal for most of us. Meditation is an invitation to reduce clutter and focus on simplicity. Rather than multitask 10 things, do one thing supremely well. Master the most important tool: your own mind. There is great power there, but it’s surprisingly difficult to get started. In recent months, I’ve come back to meditation and have expanded my practice to the point where I now spend more than an hour a day (in a few time blocks) in meditation. If I can do it, with my hyperactive attention span, anyone can do it. You can do it. Attention and focus are a lot like a muscle: exercise them and they get stronger.
One of the major points I would take issue with in the article I linked is the idea that, drawn from the title, if you want to “make a killing on Wall Street, start meditating.” Though it’s a catchy title, it is hard to imagine a more wrong-headed approach to the practice of meditation. You will see benefits, accruing slowly but surely over time, that probably far outweigh your expectations, but this is a practice that works on you as a whole person. If you narrow your focus to “being a better trader” or “respecting my stop losses” then I think you compromise the whole process and it simply won’t “work” in any meaningful sense of the word. The skills you need to navigate financial markets—clear vision, equanimity, balance, control, better intuition, impulse control, self-awareness, the ability to moderate your emotional state, etc.—will grow out of this practice, but developing those skills should not be the focus.
There is a lot of mystery surrounding meditation, and a lot of nonsense has been written about it. Over the next few weeks, as we dig deeper into what meditation is and is not in a series of posts, I’ll work to strip away some of the confusion. Know this: all meditation techniques have one thing in common—they work toward a state of clarity and for the stopping of random thoughts and influences. They usually get there through focus and relaxation. Often that focus is placed on something like a sound, an object, or an image, the meditator’s thoughts, or some sensation in her body. Though there are probably tens of thousands of meditation techniques, they all have this basic idea in common; focus on something, relax, and wait until the mind settles down and becomes clear.
So, take this post as an invitation to get started. How? Well, the easiest way is to just sit for a few minutes and see what you experience. I suggest a commitment is in order. If you play at meditation you will do it for a few days, decide it is hard and/or boring, and walk away. The only way you will accomplish anything is if you decide to do it for a certain amount of time, and then evaluate results. Again, I’d gently suggest that three months is probably an appropriate commitment. If you want to start, begin this week by setting a timer for five minutes, and then sit and pay attention to your breathing. That’s it. That’s the entire instruction: sit and pay attention to only your breathing for five minutes.
If you want, you may count your breaths, perhaps counting 1 to 10 and then starting over. Set a timer for 5 minutes, and do this twice a day. When your mind wanders, and it will (“did I send that email? Is the lettuce too far back in the refrigerator so it might freeze? You better get up and check. Did I pay that bill? Make sure you email Joe back…”) just bring your thoughts back to your breath and, once again, focus. When your mind wanders, don’t be upset or angry or tense, just gently guide your attention back to your breath and continue to breathe. Just sit and focus on your breath. Do not worry about how you sit, where you sit, what you wear, how you hold your hands, what you eat, or anything else—simply sit and breathe and you will have begun a practice that can pay incredible dividends over the next few months. I will post again in a few days, and give you some ideas for taking this practice a little but further, but why not get started today?
Great post Adam, I’ve been trying to get into meditation but running into the kind of blocks you mentioned above (lack of concentration, commitment, attention span etc), particularly with so many different takes on it on the Twitter streams – it’s difficult to know where to start and whose material to follow… I do feel a certain level of trust and transparency with your perspective on meditation and I guess I could say that about the rest of your blog too. Thanks for sharing and looking forward to the follow ups.
Start by sitting and watching your breathing. Personally, Twitter is not good for my peace of mind or focus so I might suggest avoiding that. Give me a few posts to lay some things out and see if this is a path you’d like to follow. My approach is very traditional and simple. No bells and whistles because there should be none. (Actually, there IS a place for a bell lol, but that’s a future post.)
I’ve had a regular practice of Transcendental Meditation for several years, and I’ve experienced many gradual yet clear benefits from it. The experiece of a 20-minute session in the morning and afternoon is quite pleasant; no matter how much my mind may churn at the beginning, it quiets over the time. Perhaps the most apparent benefit is that at bedtime, I quickly fall into a sound sleep. Though not meditating then, I think I easily calm my mind to prepare for sleep. TM is a specific type of practice, but shares principles of many other types of meditation.
A yoga teacher of mine describes meditation as the time between thoughts. When thoughts come, let them come. Do not be angry or disappointed that they come, just let them go. Gentle focus on the breath is a great place to start. When the mind wanders, just gently bring it back.
*** Just read the Bloomberg article. I first learned TM as a child in the 1970’s at the urging of my hippie-ish sister, then took the full adult course in 1987 while in college, long before I’d heard of Ray Dalio. The claim of meditative superiority strikes me as odd- like in a room full of very nice people, arguing who is the nicest…
Thanks, Adam; looking forward to related posts.
Thank you for the insightful comment. I plan to touch on mantra in general and will also discuss TM in a little more depth than most articles give it.
Your experience lines up nicely with mine. The faster to sleep (and also reduced need for sleep) is a benefit that comes pretty quickly.
And you summarized the entire practice of all types of meditation nicely: it’s the empty spaces between thoughts. That’s what we’re striving for, exactly.
Thank you!
Great Article ! Thank You ! 🙂
Pingback: Friday links: mentors and clones | Abnormal Returns
Nice article Adam,
I am waiting for more information about TM (I learned TM a long time ago but don’t used it properly and continual). In last coulpe of monts I have followed your recomendation about 5min breaths and it helped me to be more concetrated for trading.
Best,
Rammar